How to Identify Duplicate AA Memorabilia in a Group Archive
How to Identify Duplicate AA Memorabilia in a Group Archive
Two copies of a meeting program sit in the same box. They look identical until you turn one over and see an address crossed out in pencil. Before describing them as duplicates, record what each copy can tell you.
Keep the source attached to each item
Assign or retain an inventory number for each piece before moving it. If one came from a retired group officer while another arrived in an undated supply box, keep both source notes. Two coins made with the same design can have different evidence of use. Two printed programs can have different annotations or a correction inside.
Examine both faces and, for paper, check the inside and edges. A handwritten time change on a program may show how it was used even if the published version never changed. If an envelope came with one item, retain that relationship in the record and say when you're unsure it was original.
Record the same design without assuming the same story
An inventory entry may say “Same printed design as item 38. Different donor. Pencil correction on back.” That is enough to make items discoverable together without losing the difference. For a coin, record the milestone, front and reverse design, and any printed manufacturer information that you can actually read.
Our history of AA chips provides context on how chip practices developed. It may help explain why similar objects turn up in different groups. Treat the archive’s own ledger, dated photographs, and donation records as evidence for the object in front of you. Leave the item date open when those records are inconclusive.
Choose a reference copy if that helps researchers
A lightly handled program may be easier to scan. A marked copy may be more interesting to show within the group. Record which item you chose and why. For paper, keep the copies in separate archival enclosures if they need protection from rubbing or from fragile attachments. The National Archives guidance on storing family papers has practical examples for separating and housing documents.
Consider what a public caption would reveal. A note on the back may include a person’s name or meeting affiliation. Read the archive’s access and anonymity rules before sharing a photo, and ask the responsible archivist about restrictions already tied to the donor.
Pause before removing a second copy
Ask who can authorize a collection change and whether it needs a written record. If an item is only a spare display reproduction, the group may already have a different process for it. If it has an inventory number or a donor record, keep those records until the archivist can review it. A note that two pieces are very similar gives the next person a useful starting point without turning a sorting decision into a permanent loss.
Medallions to consider
These current designs have catalog records. A visual match alone can’t identify an archive piece.